Fear as Compass
Substance, Surrender, and the Ceiling of Development
February 22, 2023
teaching

Fear as Compass

El miedo como brújula

A reflection on the paradox of moving toward pain and fear as a path to freedom, and why hope for the future can become an obstacle to well-being that is available only now.

Fear as Compass

A reflection on the paradox of moving toward pain and fear as a path to freedom, and why hope for the future can become an obstacle to well-being that is available only now.

It is good to work on our pains and fears. That work matters. But from my position as a teacher, it is delicate not to completely remove them, because a lot can be said that would neutralize the experience of fear and pain. That would be a misguidance, because fear and pain is what wakes you up.

Go toward fear, with discernment

My teacher always said that fear is the north, the compass showing you where to go. Go toward fear. But then he added: with discernment. So don't walk in front of a bus. Because you never know how ridiculously wrong people will take your words, so you have to be clear. It is not simply "go toward fear." If someone is afraid to jump out a window, that does not mean they must do it. No. The fears worth approaching are the more irrational ones, the ones rooted in the mind's resistance rather than in genuine physical danger.

In dialogue, this distinction is very obvious to me. I can sense and understand it. There is a great deal of clarity when something reveals itself as the mind simply not wanting to go where being wants to go. And then there is that complex push and pull, where freedom wants to come through and the mind is saying, "No way." In that case, the direction is toward fear, toward pain. But it is not self-inflicted pain. The fear is already there.

The trap of manufactured suffering

This is the mistake of the monks who practiced self-flagellation, who believed that because Christ awakened through pain, they could simply create pain to help themselves wake up. No. That does not work. Life naturally provides enough experience of fear and pain without our needing to manufacture more.

I feel I should be careful here not to sound too dark, especially on a day when quite a lot of this kind of material came through. Because within all of this, there is so much well-being. What I am trying to point to now is something specific: hope is not a good thing. Hope is for something in the future, and well-being is now. Freedom is possible now. Being is now.

The paradox of hope

That is the paradox. That is the koan for the mind: you cannot have hope for it. I believe it was T.S. Eliot who wrote something like, "Do not hope, because you will hope for the wrong thing. Do not think, because you will think the wrong thing. You are not ready for hope. You are not ready." I forget the exact lines, but it is a gorgeous poem.

And so the subtlety is always in how to bring that forward: how to offer genuine energy and encouragement without promising anything, without giving hope. It is a balance. Sometimes what needs to be offered is reassurance. There is peace. There is well-being greater than you can imagine possible.